How Civilized Are We?
Book Notes: Volga to Ganga by Rahul Sankrityayan.
I finished Volga to Ganga fascinated by how far humans have travelled, and pissed off by how much we have carried with us. We learned to settle, grow food, build cities, cross oceans, and fly across continents. Journeys that once consumed months can now happen in a day.
But what happened to our values along the way? Reading this book, I kept returning to the same things. Greed. Jealousy. Control. People finding reasons to put themselves above other people. We call ourselves civilized. We still do some seriously shitty things.
Progress for whom?
Rahul Sankrityayan’s book is historical fiction, not a documentary record. Its stories move across thousands of years, using imagined lives to explore social change. That distinction matters, especially when the storytelling is convincing enough to feel like evidence. About the book
What fascinated me was the movement from one way of living to another. What disturbed me was how often somebody else seemed to pay for that progress. A settlement becomes wealthier. Who owns the land? A kingdom becomes powerful. Who fights its wars? A society develops elaborate customs. Who gets trapped inside them?
I caught myself wishing we had stayed nomads. Not because I know that life was peaceful or fair. I don’t. But because the world we built sometimes feels absurd: so much intelligence, so much production, and still so much effort spent deciding who deserves less. I don’t want to romanticize the past. I don’t want to worship the present either.
A person’s birth is not their worth
My first reaction to caste was that people doing similar work might have grouped together, and those groups eventually hardened into something ugly. But that is too neat an explanation. Caste involves birth, inherited status, marriage boundaries, and exclusion, not just occupation. Its history cannot be reduced to people choosing to work together. Background on caste
Whatever its origins, there is nothing defensible about treating another human being as untouchable. Think about that word. Not unreliable. Not cruel. Not guilty of harming someone. Untouchable.
A person condemned before they have done anything, because of the family they were born into. Dress it up in tradition, purity, or social order. It is still humiliation. No civilization gets a free pass for that.
My mother was a young widow
This part is personal. My mother became a widow at a young age. So when I read about widow burning, I cannot keep it at the comfortable distance of “something that happened in history.” I think about her.
Sati was not the experience of every widow or a universal practice across India. The 1829 Bengal regulation prohibited it within that jurisdiction; that was not an overnight end to every occurrence everywhere. Those distinctions matter historically. They do not make the practice any less horrifying. Historical background
A woman loses her husband. Why should she lose the right to her own life? I am glad that practice was outlawed. I am angry that anyone ever needed to argue against it.
The women with authority in the book’s early stories also stayed with me. I cannot take those stories as proof that women once ruled every society. But the contrast made me think about how much effort has gone into controlling women. Their bodies. Their marriages. Their work. Their freedom after a husband dies. How much of what we praise as tradition would survive if the people carrying its burden could simply refuse?
Don’t turn people into gods
I have little patience for writing that makes rulers seem divine. Praise someone’s achievements. Explain what they built. But don’t make them untouchable too. When poets and storytellers turn a king into something more than human, where do the people he harmed fit into the story? Does their suffering disappear because the verse is beautiful?
The same question applies to the author. Some portrayals in Volga to Ganga, including those involving Aryas and Asuras, left me questioning whose side I was being encouraged to take. I wanted more room for the contradictions within each society.
No civilization was perfect. I don’t want one group’s mythology replaced with another group’s certainty. An author can challenge my beliefs without earning my unquestioning agreement.
What did we actually learn as children?
I grew up hearing stories about Akbar and Birbal. The popular tales belong to folklore; they should not be read as verified accounts of conversations in Akbar’s court. National Digital Library of India
That distinction sounds obvious now. As a child, was I always making it? How much did I absorb because someone told it confidently? How often did admiration arrive before understanding? There is a horrible feeling in revisiting something you once believed and realizing how little you questioned it.
That does not mean everything we learned was a lie. But it does mean I no longer want heroes handed to me already polished. Show me what they did. Show me who benefited. Show me who suffered. Let me decide what deserves admiration.
Faith should not protect cruelty
I am not interested in declaring one religion good and another bad. What bothers me is the use of religion to make authority harder to question. When a human rule is presented as sacred, challenging it becomes more than disagreement. It becomes disobedience to something supposedly beyond argument.
My test is simple: what happens to the person at the bottom? Can they question? Can they leave? Can they live differently without being humiliated?
I cannot honestly claim that a world without religion would have had fewer problems. People can build oppressive systems without gods. But invoking a god does not make oppression respectable. Nor does invoking a nation, a revolution, or an economic theory.
Cruelty does not become acceptable because it was common
The destruction in these stories disturbed me. Conquest, plunder, people treated as obstacles, children caught in violence they had no part in creating. I understand that historical context matters. I refuse to let it become an excuse.
“It was normal then” explains something about the perpetrators’ world. It does not tell me what it felt like to the person being killed. And it certainly does not make the suffering smaller. That is what makes grand accounts of civilization difficult for me. We celebrate the empire. I keep thinking about the family underneath it.
I am not outside this
It would be easy to finish by blaming rulers, religious authorities, politicians, and billionaires. I do blame people who exploit their power.
But then I have to ask an uncomfortable question. How much of my own comfort would I surrender for somebody else? I don’t have an impressive answer.
I want less greed in the world. I also want security for myself and my family. I criticize accumulation without being particularly eager to give things up. That includes me. Period. It does not make every kind of selfishness equivalent. It does stop me from pretending the problem belongs entirely to other people.
I closed the book with questions
There are good people. There have always been people willing to resist cruelty, care for strangers, and challenge rules that everyone else accepted. My mother being able to live her life after becoming a widow is itself a reason not to say that nothing improved. But improvement is not the same as innocence. Modern life has not earned the right to congratulate itself endlessly.
Volga to Ganga left me amazed by human capability and suspicious of our self-image. We have become extraordinarily good at moving people, goods, money, and information. Why do we still struggle so badly to treat another person as someone whose life matters as much as our own?
Hold on, buddy. I am not ending this with five easy solutions. I’ll take that conversation further in the podcast. For now, I am still sitting with the question:
How civilized are we, really?